Saturday, April 10, 2010

Massey Math

Massey Energy Company (NYSE:MEE) today reinforced its total commitment to safety and provided additional context to the safety history of its mining operations.

– Since January 2009, UBB has had less than one violation per day of
inspection by MSHA, a rate consistent with national averages. Most of
the citations issued by MSHA to UBB in the last year were resolved on
the same day they were issued.

read the press release here.

I’m not a math wiz by any means, but….

As far as "less than 1 violation per day of MSHA inspection":

Mines are only required to be inspected 4 times per year. This year, MSHA enforcement personnel have already spent 51 days and have logged 803 hours inspecting the Upper Big Branch site and issued 124 citations. That works out to 2.4 per day of MSHA inspection.

In 2009, MSHA enforcement personnel logged 180 days and 2,999 hours at the Upper Big Branch mine and issued citations for 515 violations. That works out to 2.8 violations per day of MSHA inspection.

From http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/04/09/AR2010040905117.html – “MSHA said that in the past year, the Upper Big Branch mine exceeded national averages in eleven citation categories and that for the most serious type of safety violation the mine had more than 11 times the national rate.”

As far as the lost-time incident rate being better than the industry average for 17 of the past 19 years – one has to wonder if under-reporting and “encouragement” not to claim a valid work injury is more likely.

Friday, April 9, 2010

Labor Department: Massey ‘dragged its feet’ on getting nitrogen for W.Va. mine rescue

I'm sure everyone is still reading about the Massey mine disaster at Montcoal, WV. There is quite a bit of information on all of the news wires. However, I came across this tidbit on Ken Ward's Coal Tattoo blog that I found especially disturbing:

Labor Department: Massey ‘dragged its feet’ on getting nitrogen for W.Va. mine rescue

From: Coal Tattoo


If you watched or listened to the mine rescue briefing that just ended, you heard MSHA’s Kevin Stricklin talk about plans to pump nitrogen into the Upper Big Branch Mine to “inert” the toxic and explosive gases that are keeping rescue crews from resuming their work.

One reporter asked Stricklin why they didn’t try this nitrogen pumping earlier, like Tuesday morning, after rescue teams were initially ordered out of the mine for their own safety. Kevin — who is a real professional and a good fellow — was pretty diplomatic:

I can’t answer that. We’ve been talking about it for a couple of days and it just hasn’t been made available yet.

Well, I asked the Department of Labor Public Affairs office for an official answer to that question, and this is what I got via email just now from Carl Fillichio:

We asked the company for it 2 days ago. Company dragged their feet. We had to keep asking for it.

read more at Coal Tattoo.